Cover photo

Democracy and Remaking: The Case for Sortition

The industrial age is over. Our calling now is to invent the age that comes next. Doing so requires nothing short of a complete remaking of the industrial age systems that currently control us, such as the education system, the social security system, the tax code, the healthcare system, etc. The required degree of change poses a unique challenge to present day democracies which have been focused on stability. So far they have failed to rise to the occasion which has resulted in deteriorating political and social landscapes in much of the world. Unsurprisingly then we are once again hearing calls for authoritarian approaches of varying guises, some are outright backward facing (e.g. calling for aristocracy), while others point to the success of China, and yet others imagine handing over these decisions to AI. 

In today’s post I want to make the case for an alternative: A return to sortition as a democratic means of remaking.

Sortition was a core element of Athenian democracy. Sortition is the random selection of citizens to fill a position or form a deliberative group, much as we still do in the US today with juries. Athenians considered this to be superior to elections, because elections allowed the wealthy to purchase influence, a profound insight that we sadly appear to have forgotten. Athenian democracy required candidates that were selected to submit to an examination (dokimasia) to ensure their qualifications. There was also a process of accountability (euthyna) after leaving office.

I am far from the first person to propose a return to sortition. For instance, Astra Taylor mentions this as a possibility in her book on Democracy and David Chaum made a proposal on random elections in 2012. I believe we need it now more than ever because it has become abundantly clear that the present political systems are not up to the task. In the US, neither Democrats nor Republicans will ever have a sufficient mandate on their own to accomplish the degree of necessary change to the existing systems.

A recent example of sortition in action comes from Ireland. The country had a very restrictive policy as part of its constitution, which allowed abortion only in cases where the life of the mother was at risk. The Irish parliament put in place a Citizen’s Assembly of 99 randomly selected citizens (i.e. citizens selected by sortition). The citizens decided in favor of repealing the constitutional amendment and allowing parliament to legislate. This was then put to a vote of all citizens and approved as the new policy for the country with broad support for the change to the constitution.

We should avail ourselves of this mechanism to remake our major systems that are in dire need of change. We could have separate groups for social security, taxation, healthcare, education, immigration etc. Ideally the groups are selected and meet at the same time as these policies are all interrelated. For example, the introduction of basic income to replace existing social safety nets could come in the form of a negative income tax.

The path to this in the US goes via Article V of the constitution, which allows for amendments to the constitution and can be triggered by 34 states (and much less likely by a two third majority in both houses). A possible amendment could call for a one time reset of major policies through citizens assemblies letting regular politics resume after these have been agreed upon. Crucially it would have to insist on sortition to prevent the assemblies from being dominated by existing interests. I also favor a qualification examination to ensure anyone selected has sufficient command of the English language, a reasonable grounding in civics, and an ability to absorb new information. The latter is important as the assemblies will be able to call on experts, as well as use AI tools to investigate the possible effects of proposals. Finally all selected participants would need to agree to full financial transparency before, during and for several years after the assemblies to avoid external financial influence.

Now one common reaction to proposals like this is to call them “naive.” This is the go-to-word for those who consider themselves the arbiters of what is possible. They use “naive” to dismiss challenging ideas outright without engaging with its merits. The great benefit of having been a startup investor for several decades is to have heard every great startup idea dismissed as “naive” by the incumbents in the industry. So in my experience the people who use the word “naive” tend to be either incurious or invested in protecting the status quo.

I also want to point out that other people have had more far reaching proposals about holding another constitutional convention. And Jefferson himself had toyed with the idea that the Constitution and all laws should automatically expire every 19 years. Now while these proposals may be overly aggressive, they do point out that the idea that remaking may become necessary is an old one. My proposal above for a one time remaking of major systems via citizens assemblies while leaving the overall setup in place tries to strike a balance between change and stability.

Cover image is a kleroterion, the randomization device used for Athenian sortition.