Facebook and the Net

Hats off to Mark Zuckerberg and the entire team at Facebook.  They are managing that most impressive feat of innovating at scale.  They are also incredibly ambitious in what they want to accomplish.  The goal seems nothing short of one identity and one graph to “rule them all.”  With over 400 million users worldwide and a sign on system that is being widely adopted this ambition doesn’t seem crazy.  Especially when you layer on top of this the possibility that soon many of these users might have Facebook currency that could be used by sites to implement 1-click purchasing (and by venues to enable RFID based payments via Facebook presence).

But I see at least one flaw with this plan for domination.  I simply don’t believe that there is a single social graph that makes sense.  I may very well follow someone’s booksmarks on del.icio.us that I don’t want to have any other relationship with.  Or take the group of people that I feel comfortable sharing my foursquare checkins with — these are all people I trust and would enjoy if they showed up right there and then.  That group in turn is different from the people I work with on Google docs for various projects which is why I would be nervous about using the Microsoft docs connected to Facebook.  Trying to shoe-horn all of these into a single graph is unlikely to work well.

As a little historical aside.  There is a bit of a personal irony in the huge noise around the Facebook “Like” button.  Yahoo could have had this in 2005 following their acquisition of del.icio.us if they had started to promote it to their users and to content sites!

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Posted: 22nd April 2010Comments
Tags:  Facebook Microsoft Yahoo Delicious social graph Google

Newer posts

Older posts

blog comments powered by Disqus
  1. mediation reblogged this from newsweek
  2. fillup reblogged this from continuations
  3. jessehertzberg reblogged this from continuations
  4. jmhtalley reblogged this from newsweek and added:
    This question/article has been reblogged for your consideration, dear readers. I’m not sure what will eventually cause...
  5. danwick reblogged this from continuations and added:
    Facebook’s Open Graph, Twitter’s Annotations, bit.ly, Instapaper/Evernote… they all have fundamentals that could be...
  6. maggiehilliard reblogged this from continuations
  7. irq reblogged this from continuations
  8. whitneymcn reblogged this from continuations and added:
    The social graph/access/privacy concern seems very real: Facebook already has more than 30 different switches in their...
  9. newsweek reblogged this from continuations and added:
    It’s interesting...this is by far the...positive...
  10. continuations posted this

Newer posts

Older posts